|
Judith Cushman & Associates Retained Executive Search in Communications Judy Cushman's Blog |
|
The Cushman Report To subscribe to the email version of The Cushman Report, please send a note to info@jc-a.com with "subscribe" in the Subject line. Click here to view past editions. The Cushman Report Breaking News, Trends and Information about the Communications Marketplace May 1998 SALARY/JOB RESPONSIBILITIES UPDATE May marks the first anniversary of writing these newsletters. It has been tough meeting a monthly deadline, attempting to say something relevant and honest while doing my "day" job. On balance its been worth it. I promised this one would be shorter, so here goes. (I havent been able to get it back to two pages at least its divided into two sections.) The reason this letter comes at the end of May is that I have been traveling for the past few weeks nonstop to Hawaii, Chicago, Little Rock (yes, we have work there) and Palm Springs. I have one more trip in this series in early June and then I can get on with catching up which is my ongoing goal -- yet to be achieved. SALARY/JOB RESPONSIBILITIES UPDATE One of the most frequently asked questions by both candidates and clients alike is salary/total compensation ranges. Periodically, I update the figures. Now that you can reach me via e-mail, Id like to post a survey form toward mid-June asking you not only the standard questions about what you are earning, but whether there has been any significant change or anticipated change in the way or frequency your compensation is adjusted. Id be very interested in your level of satisfaction with the formula employed by your organization. These comments would form the basis of a report Id like to write in early fall. Meanwhile, heres my update on salaries tied to job responsibilities. The first three years ($20,000-$45,000). These are the tactical jobs -- junior account executives, coordinators with smaller (second tier) agencies, and non-profit #3 jobs in PR departments. This is the time to invest in a career. The watchword is hustle and "can do." Basic writing skills are all that is expected. An ability to follow instructions and to meet deadlines (say "yes" and mean it -- engender trust) is critical. By the way, interpersonal skills (being a nice person) are essential unless you are interested in research. Liking action, the "rush" from meeting a deadline, and enthusiasm lead to success. Pay attention to clues about natural talents. When assignments are handed out do you take a piece and tackle it as a single contributor? Do you solve client problems through writing e.g. an article, press release or plan? Do you naturally team up and form a small group to find solutions? Do you jump on the phone and develop ties to the media? (Are you a relationship person who really enjoys contact with your media buddies?) Are you an information maven? (Do you know what the latest news is, and do your teammates come to you for current technical or client developments?) You can tell if you are succeeding and which talents are perceived as being stronger by paying attention to these clues. In meetings are you making suggestions that your supervisors are adopting? Are you being invited to more meetings and being taken to meet clients? Is your copy being edited less? Are you being given more or less writing projects and/or being shifted to media relations contact (versus updating media lists)? The critical period from three to seven years -- Moving beyond Account Executive to Senior Account Executive to Manager or beginning Supervisor ($45,000-$70,000): During this time a junior professional with promise will succeed in making a major leap becoming a self-starter capable of initiating and adding value to client projects. He will not be a broad-based strategic contributor. He can be relied upon to make sound decision about what he can tackle on his own (and when to ask for clarification) in the area of trade and business media relations. He will have developed an ability to manage projects (such as a media tour or trade show) and he will be able to set and meet deadlines. He will also have effective people skills either as a single contributor or as a supervisor of a small team. To develop these capabilities is not only a matter of "doing" but of maturity, intelligence, and personality. Succeeding at this level requires a far more complex combination of talents than needed for a beginner. Not everyone has all the pieces and succeeding at the beginning stage is no guarantee that a professional will move to the next level. This timetable is optimal and not everyone moves so quickly. The Middle Management Professional -- Agency Supervisor to Corporate Communications Manager with seven to 10 years experience ($70,000-$100,000): This is where a successful professional makes major career decisions. He has assimilated the basics and is ready to contribute to an organization through a well-rounded skill set. There are more jobs than there are people at this level. Making the best career decision is difficult. Here are three basic paths and the critical qualities required to succeed. The agency path -- a Supervisor can continue along with a top-tier agency managing bigger clients, budgets and overseeing larger groups. The focus is on project management, multi-tasking, client relationships and new business/marketing. The direction is not primarily internal, operations or people/development intensive. Near term results not long-term strategy makes the client happy and determines success. The Start-Up or small company track -- with good all around skills, an enthusiastic high-energy self-starter, can be drawn like a bee to honey to this situation. There are "start-up junkies" who love the rush and excitement of forming a small team and "just doing it." With few resources internally, the manager must be "street smart" to cut corners and get the job done. The focus is market support and media relations; this is not brain surgery. Being strategic is very narrowly defined to project work (trade shows) and press tours. Flexibility is essential -- every day is a new challenge. There is no emphasis on long term program or people development and no time to think more than a few weeks/months ahead. This is a high-risk, high reward game and once embarked on a start-up track, a manager can expect to change positions roughly every two years. The major/large company option -- in stark contrast to the start-up, the emphasis here is on fitting in to the culture and building lasting relationships in order to solve broader more strategic problems for the organization. While short-term projects must be completed, success is gained by developing effective strategies over longer-term media issues, crisis communication, and high-level counsel to senior officers. Thoughtful and carefully written presentations are important tools to win the trust and confidence of management. Directing outside resources while developing a good (if small) internal team is essential. This position is the launching point for a rise through the middle to senior ranks. Again, the intangibles that can only be discovered through this work experience will ultimately lead to success -- such as organizational/political savvy, business intelligence and leadership capabilities. From an agency environment, it is relatively easy to move along any of these paths. However, it is very difficult to move from a start-up environment to a medium/large corporation and vice versa. If after experiencing a start-up, a young manager discovers it is not a "fit," then moving back to an agency may be an excellent option. Jumping into a stable corporation after the exhausting experience of a go-go start-up may sound very tempting. However, it requires a great deal of introspection to determine if the real appeal is simply the change of pace and need to slow down. Once youve caught your breath will the company seem boring? Professionals who havent analyzed which role suits them and taps their talents most effectively, find themselves jumping from one path to another -- oftentimes not progressing in title or level of responsibility. It is easy in this market to reach six figures. The real challenge is breaking through to senior management ranks. That is the subject for another newsletter. Ive discovered all sorts of useful information, which I will be posting in the next few weeks. In Chicago this month, at a conference called @d.tech, which is all about how to use the web for advertising, marketing/sales and effective communication, I was struck with how few advertising executives understand that the web is not about banner advertising and "sales pitches." It is far more about relationship building and information exchange, which has long been the framework for Public Relations professionals. Measuring (what is so poorly understood) is the conundrum of the advertising community now. I led a seminar about careers in communications and outlined trends, salaries and career paths which include web-based expertise. Updating salary ranges and relating them to functional responsibility is what Ill discuss later in this newsletter. I came home from Chicago really excited about starting a new on-line recruiting division, which is a natural for us, since JC&A is a pioneer in the use of the web to recruit for communications professionals. At first JC&A would offer a simple posting/referral service until we built up our database and expertise about the positions that are being created. This is a special moment to ask you to brainstorm with me at the inception of a business concept. What positions are you seeing created? Here are several job functions/titles I expect will develop: Corporate Manager of -- Integrated Message Development; Internet/Database Research; Intranet/Content; Extranet/Content; Website/Content ; Website/Technical; On-Line Advertising; Website/Design, On-line media relations (both agency and corporate), On-line financial communications (both agency and corporate) and; On-line Teleconferencing. At agencies, account managers in interactive divisions are designing websites, ad campaigns and cross-media promotions. The theme at the PRSA Counselors Academy (May 17-20th) in La Quinta, CA, was recruitment and retention. Paul Holmes, Editor of Inside Public Relations and Reputation Management said the most critical issue facing our industry is the lack of qualified professionals. One speaker said treat each job applicant like a new business referral and make hiring an ongoing investment. Another panelist said, just because applicants can walk and breathe dont hire them. She had lots more to add about the pain she has experienced and the hard lessons learned. Salary survey results presented there by faculty from Northwesterns Integrated Marketing Communications program questioned the financial model of our industry. Public Relations starting salaries are substantially below what a graduate can earn from a marketing or consulting organization -- a difference of $23,000 vs. $40,000. No wonder top performers are going elsewhere. And, yet another alarming trend is the loss of PR consulting business to those very consulting groups -- such as McKinsey or Andersen. One counselor said IBM had created a so-called PR consulting practice and pitched a client and won, more because of the brand than due to a track record or ability to offer any real expertise. (With permission from these presenters, Ill be posting more of these comments in the next few weeks.) A special word here about the issue of open communication. In this world of instant access to information and the need for our profession to embrace the internet as a powerful tool, I find it unimaginable that heads of agencies will attempt to control access to information and prevent employees from reading any material they wish -- including this newsletter. However, I respect requests from those firms not to use their e-mail systems and will not send this newsletter to employees. The firms that have asked us not to communicate with their staffs are: A&R Partners, Alexander Communications, Blanc & Otus, Connors Communications, Cunningham Communications, GCI Group, Hermanoff & Associates, Lois Paul & Partners, Insync, MWW, Roher PR, Rourke MS&L, S&S, and Schwartz Communications. Of course, this newsletter may be sent to personal addresses. I welcome hearing from potential subscribers with that information. |
|
Judith Cushman & Associates 15600 NE 8th St., Suite B1, PMB 178, Bellevue, WA 98008 s (425) 392-8660 Fax (425) 746-8629jcushman@jc-a.com s www.jc-a.com The Judith Cushman & Associates web team would appreciate feedback concerning this site. Please e-mail your comments, questions and suggestions to heathers@jc-a.com. |
|
|
Copyright © 2007 JJG&R Communications Services, Inc. |
|